A 2024 study from Fox Chase Cancer Center found that an inherited gene change makes asbestos more dangerous. It does not take asbestos out of the picture.
Many people, including some judges and jurors, assume that most cancer comes from lifestyle or genes. Cancer caused by work or the environment is different. Most mesotheliomas are linked to asbestos exposure, usually at work, according to the American Cancer Society. The CDC has estimated that about 85% of mesotheliomas in men are attributable to asbestos exposure at work.
When a person with mesothelioma brings a claim, the defense sometimes points to genes instead of asbestos.
Research on inherited cancer risk does not support that argument. A gene change can make a person more vulnerable to asbestos, but the asbestos exposure is still a cause of the disease. And in most states the law protects vulnerable people rather than excusing those who harmed them. More on that below.

Researchers at Fox Chase Cancer Center, part of Temple University Health System, studied how an inherited gene change affects the cancer risk from asbestos.
What the Study Found
The study, led by Joseph Testa and Yuwaraj Kadariya, was published on April 8, 2024, in the journal Cancer Research Communications and presented the same day at the American Association for Cancer Research annual meeting (study page).
The researchers worked with mice. Some carried an inherited change (a germline mutation) in a gene called BAP1; their littermates had normal genes. Over four years, the mice were given low doses of one of two kinds of asbestos, crocidolite (an amphibole) or chrysotile (the kind used most in commerce), injected into the abdomen.
- At every dose, the mice with the BAP1 mutation developed mesothelioma more often and sooner than mice with normal genes.
- Low doses of either kind of asbestos also caused mesothelioma in some mice with normal genes.
- Chrysotile caused tumors with a stronger immune-suppressing response, which may help tumors hide from the immune system. The authors suggest immunotherapy could one day help BAP1 carriers who develop mesothelioma.
The study also speaks to an old argument. Some have claimed that chrysotile causes mesothelioma only when it is contaminated with amphibole fibers. Here, minimal chrysotile exposure alone raised the mesothelioma rate in BAP1-mutant mice.
What the study can and can't show
This was an animal study, and the asbestos was injected, not breathed in. It does not tell us how many human mesotheliomas involve an inherited gene change. What it does show is the pattern that matters in court: the mutation made the mice more vulnerable to asbestos, even at low doses. The gene raised the risk; asbestos was the exposure that the gene made more dangerous.
Genes and Cancer Risk
Some people inherit genes that raise their risk of cancer.
Researchers have identified a growing list of cancer predisposition genes. Up to about 10% of cancers arise through an inherited mutation in one of these genes, according to a 2016 review. An inherited risk is not a certainty: carriers are more likely to develop cancer, not certain to.
For mesothelioma, people who carry an inherited BAP1 change are at higher risk when exposed to asbestos. Mesothelioma runs in families only in rare cases. Current cancer guidelines recommend offering genetic testing to all mesothelioma patients, mainly because the results can matter for treatment and for relatives. A gene test result does not, by itself, prove or rule out the role of asbestos in a person's disease. Our mesothelioma page explains more.
Other Kinds of Claims
Genetics rarely comes up outside a lawsuit. Many people with mesothelioma also have other options:
- Asbestos trust claims. Bankruptcy trusts set up by former asbestos makers review medical and exposure records under their own rules. See asbestos trust claims.
- Social Security disability. Mesothelioma is on Social Security's Compassionate Allowances list, which speeds the decision. SSDI payments start after a five-month waiting period, and Medicare coverage follows 24 months after payments begin. See Social Security disability claims.
- VA disability compensation. Veterans whose disease VA connects to asbestos exposure in service may qualify. When the evidence for and against service connection is roughly in balance, VA gives the veteran the benefit of the doubt. See VA disability claims.
- Workers' compensation. Rules vary by state; the worker generally must show the disease came from work. See workers' compensation.
Legal Issues
In a lawsuit against a company that made or sold asbestos products, the claim is often based on negligence (failure to use reasonable care, including failure to warn about known hazards) or strict product liability. See understanding mesothelioma lawsuits. Punitive damages are available in some states, but only for especially bad conduct, and the standards vary by state.
Once a claim is made, a defendant may try to deny responsibility or reduce the damages. Two legal ideas often answer a "genetics" defense.
Substantial vs. Contributing Cause
A disease can have more than one cause. In many states, a person with an asbestos disease must show that exposure to a defendant's product was a substantial factor in causing it. A gene that made the person more vulnerable does not make the asbestos exposure any less a cause.
Smoking is a major cause of lung cancer, but it is not listed among the risk factors for mesothelioma by the American Cancer Society.
The Eggshell Skull Rule
The general rule is that a defendant takes an injured person as it finds them. This is sometimes called the "eggshell skull rule." A person who was more vulnerable to begin with, because of a gene or for another reason, is still entitled to bring a claim, and in most states a defendant cannot avoid responsibility by pointing to that vulnerability. How a genetic finding plays out in a particular case depends on the medical evidence and the state's law.
Our take
What this means if you have, or may have, an asbestos claim
This study doesn't change who can bring a claim, but it supports what we see in our cases: an inherited gene can make asbestos more dangerous, and it does not excuse the exposure. If you have mesothelioma and your doctor recommends genetic testing, the result matters for your care and your family, and a positive result does not mean you have no claim. Keep a record of your jobs and the products you worked around. Our mesothelioma page explains causes, genetics and claims.
Read something that sounds familiar? Free case review. No records or product names needed, and no fee unless we recover compensation for your family.
Sources
- Fox Chase Cancer Center, "Fox Chase Cancer Center Researchers Show Mutation Increases Susceptibility to Asbestos-Induced Malignant Mesothelioma" (Apr. 8, 2024)
- Kadariya Y. et al., "Low Exposures to Amphibole or Serpentine Asbestos in Germline Bap1-mutant Mice Induce Mesothelioma Characterized by an Immunosuppressive Tumor Microenvironment," Cancer Research Communications 2024;4(4):1004-1015
- American Cancer Society, Risk Factors for Malignant Mesothelioma
- CDC, "Malignant Mesothelioma Mortality in Women, United States, 1999–2020," MMWR 2022;71(19)
- Wang Q., "Cancer predisposition genes: molecular mechanisms and clinical impact on personalized cancer care," Acta Pharmacologica Sinica 2016
- Kindler H.L. et al., "Treatment of pleural mesothelioma: ASCO guideline update," J Clin Oncol 2025
- 38 CFR 3.102, Reasonable doubt (VA)
- Mesothelioma (our guide)
- Social Security disability claims (our guide)
This post is news and commentary, provided for general information. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.