Asbestos may be a rarity in today's market, but its toxic legacy lives on.
Earlier this year, a Florida family shared a worrying story with ABC Action News: at the RV park where they live in Dunedin, in Pinellas County near Tampa and St. Petersburg, a dumpster carrying a sign warning that asbestos may cause cancer or lung damage sat just a few dozen feet from their home.
Ryane Smith lives full-time in an RV at Sun Retreats Dunedin with her family, including two young sons. Hurricane Helene's storm surge damaged mobile homes in the park, and 27 of them, according to Pinellas County, were being demolished. Some contained asbestos.
Smith contacted local media after realizing that asbestos waste from the demolished homes was going into a rusty dumpster with visible holes, "maybe like 20 or 30 feet" from her family's RV.
When ABC Action News visited, the dumpster was covered with a large plastic sheet sealed around the rim with duct tape. According to Smith, it had not been fully sealed until recently, and the sea breeze sometimes lifted the sheet.
"That's what's freaking me out through all of this," Smith told ABC Action News.
Pinellas County's Air Quality Division, which was monitoring the abatement and demolition, said the project had largely gone smoothly and in compliance with the federal asbestos air rules (the National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants, or NESHAP). The dumpster's owner, JES Abatement, said the dumpster was in compliance but would be moved after the complaints, and a Sun Retreats regional vice president said it would be moved within days and taken off the property the following week.
Smith's story is unusual, but the underlying problem is not. Millions of older American homes, schools and workplaces still contain asbestos materials, and storms, renovation and demolition can disturb them.
Asbestos Is Off Most of the Market, but It Isn't Gone
Few people today doubt that asbestos is dangerous.
Over decades, federal rules tightened on asbestos. Faced with regulation and a wave of injury lawsuits, many asbestos companies went bankrupt, and many set up trusts to pay injured people.
However, the risks of asbestos exposure weren't always public knowledge, even when some manufacturers knew them.
History of Asbestos Use
Up until the 1970s, asbestos was used widely in American industry. Because it is strong and fire-resistant, it went into a multitude of different products, and companies marketed asbestos materials as safe and modern.
Asbestos could be found in automotive brakes, boiler and pipe insulation, vinyl floor tiles, heat-resistant gloves, and even, from 1952 to 1956, the "Micronite" filter of Kent cigarettes. Some cosmetic talc was also found to be contaminated with asbestos.
Asbestos was never fully banned in the United States until recently. EPA's 1989 ban on most asbestos products was largely overturned by a federal appeals court in 1991, leaving only a few products and new uses banned. Use fell sharply anyway. In March 2024, EPA banned the ongoing uses of chrysotile asbestos, the last kind still imported. Many homes built with asbestos materials decades ago still contain them, and many of those products have survived decades of use intact.
This "legacy" asbestos is a large problem. In November 2024, EPA concluded that disturbing and handling legacy asbestos poses an unreasonable risk to health, while undisturbed asbestos in an older building does not present a risk to the people in it. Work that disturbs it is regulated: NESHAP covers demolition, renovation and waste disposal, and OSHA covers workers. Nobody knows exactly how many Americans are exposed today. Asbestos remains in many schools and office buildings, and in places like New York City subway tunnels.
Asbestos Exposure Is Often Unnoticeable
Asbestos causes serious diseases, including malignant mesothelioma, an aggressive cancer of the lining of the lungs or abdomen.
Exposure isn't always noticeable. Many surviving asbestos products, like vinyl floor tiles and old pipe insulation, don't look like they contain asbestos. As these materials age and break down, or are cut, sanded or torn out, they can release microscopic fibers into the air.
Asbestos exposure can happen in several different ways, including the following.
Occupational asbestos exposure
Occupational asbestos exposure is exposure at work. In the past it was by far the most common kind, because workers in many industries, like manufacturing, shipbuilding and the building trades, worked with and around asbestos materials every day.
Secondary asbestos exposure
Secondary asbestos exposure, also called "take-home," "household" or "para-occupational" exposure, happens when a worker brings asbestos fibers home on clothes and in hair. The fibers can settle on furniture or get mixed in with the family laundry, exposing everyone in the household, including children who never worked with asbestos.
Environmental asbestos exposure
Environmental asbestos exposure comes from asbestos in the air, soil or water outside the workplace.
Natural and man-made sources
Some exposure comes from naturally occurring asbestos in rock, found in parts of California and other states. It is mainly a concern when the rock is disturbed by construction, quarrying or road work.
Other exposure comes from people: asbestos released from mines and plants, or from buildings during renovation, demolition, storms and fires. That is the worry at Sun Retreats, where officials said the work was being done under the federal rules.
Your Rights After Asbestos Exposure
Being exposed to asbestos does not mean you will get sick. According to the National Cancer Institute, low levels of asbestos are present in air, water and soil, and most people do not become ill from their exposure. The risk rises with how much asbestos a person breathed and for how long.
One of asbestos's biggest dangers is how slowly it causes disease.
Latency: asbestos diseases can take decades to appear.
Unlike the flu or a cold, asbestos diseases have very long latency periods. The National Cancer Institute says it can take 10 to 40 years or more for symptoms of an asbestos-related condition, such as pleural mesothelioma, asbestosis or lung cancer, to appear.
Speak to an Asbestos Attorney About Compensation (Sometimes Without a Lawsuit)
If you or a loved one has an asbestos disease, you may not have to bear the cost alone. Juries and courts across the United States have held many asbestos manufacturers responsible for the harm their products caused to workers, their families and others.
The Law Offices of Justinian C. Lane, Esq.-PLLC, helps people diagnosed with asbestos diseases and their families. Depending on the circumstances of your exposure, our team can:
- Determine whether you may be able to file an asbestos lawsuit
- Conduct an investigation into how, when and where you were exposed to asbestos
- Use tools like W.A.R.D., our in-house database of asbestos exposure information, to identify the companies responsible
- Represent you in settlement negotiations or at trial
Outside of court, many people with asbestos diseases may also be able to file claims with asbestos bankruptcy trusts, which usually doesn't require a lawsuit.
Our take
What this means if you have, or may have, an asbestos claim
A dumpster of sealed asbestos waste is not the kind of exposure that usually leads to asbestos disease, and the county said this job was being run under the federal rules. If an older building near you is being torn down, stay away from the dust and report open or leaking waste containers to your local air quality office. The people who do have a claim question are those who worked with asbestos for months or years, or lived with someone who did. If that's you, see Were you exposed? for what your risk really is and our free health test.
Read something that sounds familiar? Free case review. No records or product names needed, and no fee unless we recover compensation for your family.
Sources
This post is news and commentary, provided for general information. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.