City crews recently finished cleaning up after a steam main leak on Manhattan's Upper East Side. The leak, at a manhole on Park Avenue between East 69th and 70th streets, broke out on the afternoon of July 31, 2024. It threw debris into the air and snarled traffic. Tests on the debris found asbestos, and city officials at first asked nearby residents to keep their windows closed. Con Edison later said its complete air sampling results were negative. Ten nearby customers lost heat and hot water for part of the next day.
The leak is a reminder that asbestos is still part of the city's old infrastructure, including the steam pipes and tunnels under its streets.
The Persistence of Asbestos in Public Structures
Asbestos is a group of naturally occurring fibrous minerals. It was widely used in building materials because it is durable, resists fire and insulates well. Its fibers are a health risk when they get into the air and are breathed in: asbestos causes asbestosis (scarring of the lungs), mesothelioma, and cancers of the lung, larynx and ovary. Because it was used so widely, asbestos is still found in many older buildings and systems, especially in older cities like New York.
That includes steam pipes. Older steam pipes were often wrapped in asbestos insulation. When a Con Edison steam main ruptured near Grand Central in 2007, asbestos was found in the debris and the site was treated as an asbestos containment area. Con Edison has since replaced asbestos insulation in its manholes and where crews repair steam pipes, but other asbestos-wrapped pipe remains in place, because replacing all of it would mean digging up much of Manhattan's streets.
Asbestos in Cement: A Continuing Hazard
People have used asbestos for thousands of years, but its use took off with industrialization in the late 1800s, when it became a staple in factories, skyscrapers and ships for insulation and fireproofing.
Mixing asbestos fiber into cement made strong, light, fire-resistant products. Asbestos-cement pipe, flat and corrugated sheets, siding and shingles were used in industrial, commercial and residential buildings for much of the 20th century.
Asbestos use in the U.S. fell sharply around 1980 as the health risks became undeniable. Ordinary poured concrete generally did not contain asbestos, but asbestos-cement products were common, so buildings and water systems built before then may contain them. Asbestos-cement pipe is not known to be made in the U.S. today. When EPA banned the ongoing uses of chrysotile asbestos in March 2024, the uses still known in the U.S. were chlorine-plant diaphragms, sheet gaskets, oilfield brake blocks, aftermarket brakes and other vehicle friction products, and other gaskets, not cement pipe.
Health Risks and Necessary Precautions for Legacy Asbestos
The health risks of asbestos are severe and well documented. Asbestos is the main known cause of mesothelioma, a rare and aggressive cancer. It also causes lung cancer, asbestosis and pleural thickening. These diseases have long latency periods: symptoms may not appear for 10 to 40 years or more after exposure.
Asbestos-cement products are fairly stable when intact. They release fibers mainly when they are broken, cut, drilled, sanded or badly weathered. Workers who cut or break them need proper respirators, protective clothing and decontamination, and the work must follow federal and state asbestos rules.
The Use of Asbestos Concrete in Waterways
Asbestos is usually thought of as an airborne hazard. It can also be found in drinking water, from natural deposits and from the decay of asbestos-cement water mains.
Historical and Ongoing Concerns
Studies in the 1970s found asbestos fibers in drinking water. In Duluth, Minnesota, tests in 1973 found 1 to 30 million asbestos-like fibers per liter of tap water. The source was taconite mining waste dumped into Lake Superior, not pipes. A Duluth cancer study found a temporary excess of pancreatic cancer cases that later declined, and cancer incidence rates otherwise similar to Minneapolis and St. Paul. In the San Francisco Bay Area, where water supplies run through natural serpentine rock, a 1980 study found statistical associations between chrysotile counts in tract drinking water and several cancers. Studies of this kind compare areas, not individual people, and can't show cause. A 1984 Utah study of towns using asbestos-cement pipe found no consistent increase in cancer, though its authors called the results preliminary.
Health Risks and Regulatory Responses
The health effects of swallowing asbestos are much less clear than those of breathing it. EPA's drinking water standard lists the health concern from long-term exposure above the limit as an "increased risk of developing benign intestinal polyps." Under the Safe Drinking Water Act, EPA's enforceable limit for public water systems, in effect since 1992, is 7 million fibers longer than 10 micrometers per liter. Water systems must test for asbestos, and if levels are consistently too high they must treat the water and notify the public.
Current Uses and Mismanagement Risks
Many U.S. water systems still have asbestos-cement mains in the ground. As asbestos-cement pipe ages, it can shed fibers into the water it carries, and cutting or breaking it during repairs can release fibers into the air.
Recommendations for Improved Safety
Local and state governments should know where asbestos-cement mains and asbestos-insulated pipes are, test as the law requires, and follow federal and state rules when that material is repaired, removed or thrown away. If you are concerned about your water, your water utility's annual water quality report shows its test results.
Importance of Asbestos Testing
The Upper East Side leak is a reminder that asbestos is hidden in many layers of city infrastructure. Knowing where it is, and testing debris and air when that material is disturbed, is how officials decide what advice to give the public.
Professional Asbestos Abatement a Must
Asbestos in buildings and utility systems has to be handled carefully. Asbestos abatement, the work of removing, sealing or enclosing asbestos, requires trained, licensed workers and strict safety practices.
Rigorous Testing and Professional Abatement
Testing is the first step. An accredited inspector takes samples of suspect materials for laboratory analysis, and air sampling can measure fibers in the air. Only trained, certified professionals should do this work, on large and small jobs alike.
Depending on the material and where it is, abatement contractors use one of these approaches:
-
Encapsulation: Sealing asbestos materials to prevent fiber release
-
Enclosure: Building a physical barrier around asbestos materials
-
Removal: Taking asbestos materials out entirely
Using qualified, experienced professionals reduces the risk of exposure for workers, residents and the surrounding area.
Cautions Against Unscrupulous Practices
Asbestos work and asbestos health claims both depend on honest reporting. In a federal civil case brought by BNSF Railway, a jury found in 2023 that the Center for Asbestos Related Disease (CARD), a clinic in Libby, Montana, had submitted 337 false claims that made patients eligible for Medicare and other benefits, and the court ordered the clinic to pay nearly $6 million in damages and penalties. That case was about a health clinic, not abatement, but it shows why accurate records matter.
When asbestos must be dealt with, property owners and officials should use accredited professionals who follow safety standards and the law.
Asbestos Exposure and Natural Disasters
As seen in other parts of the country, such as the wildfires in Maui, disasters can release asbestos by damaging older buildings that contain it. That makes asbestos part of disaster planning and cleanup.
Regulatory and Public Health Responses
Asbestos already in place does not go away on its own. Managing it takes enforcement of the rules on asbestos work and disposal, and clear public information when material is disturbed.
Decisive, Informed Action
The Upper East Side leak is a reminder of the asbestos still hidden in our cities. As New York repairs and replaces its aging infrastructure, knowing where asbestos is and removing it safely will matter for workers and the public alike.
Our take
What this means if you have, or may have, an asbestos claim
A one-time event like this leak, where air tests came back negative, is very unlikely to cause asbestos disease in passersby or neighbors. The people at real risk from New York's buried asbestos are the ones who worked on it over the years: steamfitters, pipefitters, insulators, utility and tunnel workers, and the families they came home to. If that was your job, tell your doctor about it, and keep any records of where you worked. Our page on pipefitters and plumbers explains how this kind of exposure happened, and Were you exposed? describes our free health test.
Read something that sounds familiar? Free case review. No records or product names needed, and no fee unless we recover compensation for your family.
Sources
- ABC7 New York, Steam leak spews asbestos, impacts traffic on Upper East Side's Park Avenue (Aug. 1, 2024)
- Wikipedia, 2007 New York City steam explosion
- Insulation Outlook, What Lies Beneath?
- EPA, Biden-Harris Administration finalizes ban on ongoing uses of asbestos (March 18, 2024)
- EPA, National Primary Drinking Water Regulations
- EPA archive, Consumer Factsheet on Asbestos
- Sigurdson et al., Cancer morbidity investigations: lessons from the Duluth study, Environ Res 1981
- Kanarek et al., Asbestos in drinking water and cancer incidence in the San Francisco Bay area, Am J Epidemiol 1980
- Sadler et al., Asbestos-cement pipe and cancer incidence in Utah communities, J Community Health 1984
- National Cancer Institute, Asbestos Exposure and Cancer Risk (fact sheet)
This post is news and commentary, provided for general information. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.