No fee unless we recover compensation for your family Text size 833-4-ASBESTOS (833-427-2378) Free Case Review

Courts & policy

The $6 Million Dollar Scam – Company Pays for Falsified Asbestos Report

Update, November 2026: The Ninth Circuit upheld the verdict in September 2024. BNSF later had the clinic's property seized in May 2025 to collect what it said it was owed, and after its federal grant was not renewed, CARD closed for good in August 2026.

The Center for Asbestos Related Disease (CARD), a federally funded clinic in Libby, Montana, was found by a federal jury to have submitted 337 false claims of asbestos-related disease. BNSF Railway brought the case under the federal False Claims Act, which lets a private party sue on the government's behalf. BNSF said the clinic's diagnoses made patients eligible for Medicare and other benefits they should not have received.

"The decision to pursue this litigation was not taken lightly," a BNSF spokeswoman said in 2021, when the case became public. "BNSF found very concerning allegations of fraud related to work at the Center for Asbestos Related Disease, Inc."

The case went to trial in Missoula in June 2023. BNSF challenged more than 2,000 of the clinic's diagnoses. A seven-person jury found that 337 of the claims were false and that they cost the government more than $1 million.

CARD was set up to screen and care for people exposed to asbestos in and around Libby, the site of one of the worst environmental asbestos disasters in the United States. It is funded mainly by federal grants.

Vermiculite from the nearby W.R. Grace & Co. mine was contaminated with asbestos. BNSF's trains hauled it through town, and Montana courts have said the railroad contributed to the pollution. A federal study counted 694 people in the Libby area who died from 1979 to 2011 with at least one asbestos-related cause of death. EPA placed Libby on its Superfund list in 2002, after news reports that mine workers and their families were getting sick and dying.

"The focus of this trial was on CARD's treatment of the hundreds of people who were not sick. It's a sad chapter in this saga that this trial was necessary to restore the focus on those who are truly impacted and who should continue to have access to the benefits and care they deserve," said BNSF spokeswoman Lena Kent. She said the clinic's actions wasted taxpayer money and took resources from people with real needs.

In a July 18, 2023 ruling, U.S. District Judge Dana Christensen ordered the clinic to pay the government almost $6 million in damages and penalties. As the law requires, he tripled the $1.1 million in damages found by the jury, to almost $3.3 million, and added $2.6 million in penalties.

BNSF, which filed the suit in 2019, was awarded 25 percent of the proceeds, as the False Claims Act allows. Federal prosecutors declined to join the case, and no criminal charges have been brought against the clinic. The judge said he was concerned that the clinic's doctor, Brad Black, had diagnosed himself with an asbestos-related disease, and that a nurse had approved benefits for her own mother. He wrote that the clinic showed "a reckless disregard for proper medical procedure and the legal requirements of government programs."

CARD's defense relied on the special Libby provision in the 2010 Affordable Care Act, which gives Libby-area residents with an asbestos-related diagnosis access to Medicare. Former U.S. Senator Max Baucus of Montana helped write that provision, but the court barred his testimony on the clinic's behalf.

According to court documents, the clinic has certified more than 3,400 people with asbestos-related disease and has received more than $20 million in federal funding.

The clinic's lawyers appealed the verdict to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Its director, Tracy McNew, warned that the clinic could be forced into bankruptcy if it had to pay the full judgment, and CARD filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in August 2023.

Health Effects of Asbestos and the Burden of Proof

The case turned on proof: whether each patient's diagnosis met the medical standard. That matters for asbestos claims too. Asbestos-related diseases usually appear 10 to 40 years or more after exposure, and anyone who files a claim must show proof of an asbestos-related illness and of exposure.

The best known of these diseases is mesothelioma, a rare and aggressive cancer of the lining of the lungs, abdomen or heart. Its symptoms can include chest pain, shortness of breath and fatigue. Treatment may include surgery, chemotherapy, immunotherapy and radiation.

Asbestosis is scarring of the lungs caused by heavy or long exposure. It makes breathing harder over time, and treatment includes medication and oxygen. Asbestos can also cause pleural plaques and thickening.

The International Agency for Research on Cancer has found that asbestos causes cancers of the lung, larynx and ovary, as well as mesothelioma, and there is limited evidence for cancers of the throat (pharynx), stomach and colon. Asbestos trusts pay claims for mesothelioma, asbestosis and lung cancer when the medical and exposure rules are met; other cancers are paid rarely, if at all.

If you have been diagnosed with an asbestos-related disease, a lawyer who handles these cases can help you gather the medical records and work history a claim needs. The free asbestos health test is a starting point for people who were exposed but have not been diagnosed.

Our take

What this means if you have, or may have, an asbestos claim

This case was about how one clinic certified people for federal benefits. It does not change the fact that Libby vermiculite caused real and serious disease. For any asbestos claim, what counts is a sound diagnosis from qualified doctors and proof of where you were exposed. If you lived or worked in Libby, handled Zonolite vermiculite, or lived with a Grace worker, keep your X-ray and CT readings, medical records and work history together, and have a lawyer check which trusts and companies may be responsible. Our Montana exposure sites page is a good next step.

Following this story

Libby, Montana · every post, in order · All posts on this story

  1. June 16, 2022WR Grace and Vermiculite Asbestos Lawsuit
  2. May 1, 2024 · you are hereThe $6 Million Dollar Scam – Company Pays for Falsified Asbestos Report
  3. May 27, 2024Expose: W.R. Grace’s Cancer Cover-Up
  4. June 9, 2025Asbestos News Update: Libby, Montana

Read something that sounds familiar? Free case review. No records or product names needed, and no fee unless we recover compensation for your family.

Call 833-4-ASBESTOS Request a review
Sources

This post is news and commentary, provided for general information. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.