No fee unless we recover compensation for your family Text size 833-4-ASBESTOS (833-427-2378) Free Case Review

From the archives

Kent Asbestos Cigarette Filters: Danger Upon Danger

Industry has a history of concealing the health and safety dangers of products.

Millions of people have paid a price for corporate cover-ups. In recent years, oil companies have joined the list, over documents showing their own scientists warned them about climate change.

In 2015, journalists at InsideClimate News reported, from Exxon's internal documents, that a senior Exxon scientist had told the company's management in 1977 that carbon dioxide from fossil fuels was the likely cause of a warming climate. Scientific American reported that Exxon later spent more than $30 million on groups that promoted doubt about climate change, according to Greenpeace.1

The U.S. has a long tradition of using lawsuits to hold companies to account for hiding the dangers of their products, and asbestos is one of the clearest examples.

The great asbestos cover-up

Beginning in the 1970s, asbestos companies were found liable in court for failing to warn people about the dangers of their products. The link between asbestos dust and serious lung disease had been in the medical literature since the 1920s.

Company records show that asbestos makers knew about these reports, and about disease among their own workers, decades before they warned anyone. Their concern, as their letters show, was lawsuits and publicity.

Corporate Cover-Ups Can Kill

In 1977, the asbestos industry's decades-long cover-up was exposed.

In 1977, a lawyer for former workers at a Raybestos-Manhattan plant in New Jersey obtained the files of the company's longtime president, Sumner Simpson. These letters, now known as the Sumner Simpson Papers, date mostly from 1929 to 1948, and show leaders of Raybestos-Manhattan and Johns-Manville discussing asbestos disease among their workers and how to keep it out of the public eye.

Other company files, uncovered in later lawsuits, show more. In 1933, Johns-Manville settled 11 asbestosis suits on the condition that the workers' lawyer never bring another such claim against it. And in 1948, when an industry-funded study at Saranac Laboratory found tumors in mice exposed to asbestos, the sponsoring companies insisted that the references to cancer be deleted from the report.

Big Tobacco's history of misinformation

Sadly, this pursuit of profit at all costs didn't end with the asbestos industry.

In 1950, the British Medical Journal published a study by Richard Doll and Austin Bradford Hill linking smoking to lung cancer. In 1954, their study of British doctors pointed the same way. Lawsuits against cigarette makers followed.

The Tobacco Master Settlement Agreement

In November 1998, the attorneys general of 46 states, along with the District of Columbia and five U.S. territories, signed the Master Settlement Agreement with the four largest U.S. cigarette makers. The companies agreed to stop a range of marketing practices and to pay the states billions of dollars every year, with no end date.

Tobacco companies still make and profit from cigarettes, knowing the harm they cause and that their product is highly addictive.

It is hard to believe that a carcinogen as dangerous as asbestos was added to a product that already caused cancer, and then sold as a health protection.

But that's what Lorillard Tobacco did. In 1952 it introduced Kent cigarettes with a "Micronite" filter, made in part from crocidolite asbestos, and advertised that the filter would protect smokers from much of the harm in cigarette smoke.

Kent cigarette Micronite filters

The filter material was made for Lorillard by Hollingsworth & Vose. A Cambridge University museum account says about 25% of the filter was crocidolite. Kent smokers trusted that it was a modern, safer way to smoke.

Crocidolite, also called blue asbestos, is generally considered the most dangerous type of asbestos for causing mesothelioma.

Crocidolite fibers are fine and sharp, and like other asbestos fibers they can lodge permanently in lung tissue. All types of asbestos cause cancer, but crocidolite has the strongest link to mesothelioma.

In court, Lorillard has argued that the amount of fiber released when its filters were smoked was negligible.

The asbestos version of the filter was used from 1952 until at least mid-1956. By then, smokers had bought an estimated 11 to 12 billion of the asbestos-filtered cigarettes. Without knowing it, they were adding crocidolite to the harm of the tobacco itself.

In 1995, researchers tested original Kent cigarettes from unopened 1950s packs. One filter held about 10 mg of crocidolite, and crocidolite fibers came out in the smoke of the first two puffs of every cigarette tested. At those rates, a pack-a-day smoker would have inhaled more than 131 million crocidolite fibers longer than 5 microns in a year.2

Decades later, Lorillard was still answering for this in court. In September 2013, a Florida jury awarded $8 million to Richard Delisle, a 74-year-old man with mesothelioma who said he had smoked Kents as a teenager (he had also worked with asbestos gaskets). The jury put 22% of the fault on Lorillard and 22% on Hollingsworth & Vose; because of an agreement between the two companies, Lorillard's share came to about $3.5 million. Kent cases are rare and hard to win, though: the plaintiff's lawyer said only about five had ever succeeded nationwide, and other juries have found for the companies.3

Asbestos and smoking: a dangerous combination

Many smokers who develop lung disease in later life blame it on cigarettes alone. But a 2019 review of the research on asbestos, smoking and lung cancer found:4

  • that asbestos and tobacco smoke act together, not separately, in causing lung cancer
  • that the combined risk fits a multiplicative model: a smoker exposed to asbestos has a far higher risk of lung cancer than a smoker who wasn't exposed
  • that any asbestos exposure, even in a heavy smoker, contributes to causing the cancer

Conclusion

Asbestos is no longer used in cigarettes. And far fewer Americans smoke: in 2018, 13.7% of adults smoked cigarettes, about two-thirds fewer than in 1965.5 Yet cigarette makers keep fighting to stay in the game.

At least the industry is now more tightly regulated, and asbestos is no longer in its products. Whether the oil industry will be held to account in the same way remains to be seen.

Our take

What this means if you have, or may have, an asbestos claim

If you smoked Kent cigarettes between 1952 and 1956, or worked where the Micronite filters were made, tell your doctor, because that was a real crocidolite exposure. For people who later developed mesothelioma, that history may support a claim, though Kent cases are hard to prove and often turn on remembering the brand and the years. Most people with asbestos disease were also exposed at work, so write down every job and product. Our page on asbestos in consumer products covers this and other everyday sources.

Read something that sounds familiar? Free case review. No records or product names needed, and no fee unless we recover compensation for your family.

Call 833-4-ASBESTOS Request a review
Sources

This post is news and commentary, provided for general information. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.