Update, November 2026: In June 2025 EPA said it would reconsider the 2024 chrysotile asbestos rule, then dropped that plan in July 2025; the rule remains in force and is being challenged in federal court. FDA withdrew its proposed talc testing rule on November 28, 2025, and says it will propose a new one.
Will the New Administration Further Erode the Toxic Substances Control Act?
The Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA), enacted in 1976, was designed to regulate the manufacture, importation, processing, and distribution of chemicals in the United States. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) carries it out. The law gives EPA authority to evaluate chemicals and to restrict or ban those that pose an unreasonable risk, including asbestos.
The Toxic Substances Control Act Gets Updated
In 2016, Congress amended TSCA with the Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act. The update required EPA to evaluate the risks of chemicals already on the market, on deadlines, and removed the "least burdensome" requirement that had doomed EPA's 1989 asbestos ban. It also limited companies' ability to keep chemical information confidential.
Before 2016, TSCA was widely criticized as too weak to ban even asbestos. During President Trump's first term, EPA pulled back on several chemical rules. For example, proposed bans on certain uses of trichloroethylene (TCE) and N-methylpyrrolidone (NMP), chemicals linked to cancer and other harm, were put on hold.
Based on campaign statements and the first term's record, many people expect the second administration to take a similar deregulatory approach.
The 2025 Presidential Administration & TSCA Enforcement
Focused on Deregulation
The administration has emphasized reducing regulatory burdens. Supporters argue this helps the economy. Critics say it has come at the expense of public health, especially chemical safety. In its first term, the administration proposed deep cuts to EPA's budget, including a 31 percent cut in its first budget request, and EPA slowed several chemical rules. Critics expect more of the same in this term.
This time around, EPA is expected to keep chemical regulations steady or loosen them, possibly narrowing the scope of risk evaluations and enforcement under TSCA. New chemicals matter to manufacturing, agriculture and consumer goods. But innovation should not come at the cost of public health. Less oversight can let companies move faster, and can also expose workers and consumers to more risk from substances such as asbestos and contaminated talc.
Asbestos and Talc: A Case Study in Regulatory Challenges
Asbestos is a naturally occurring mineral once prized for its strength and heat resistance. It was widely used in construction and industry, and it is a known cause of mesothelioma, lung cancer, asbestosis and other diseases.
Talc is a different mineral, used in cosmetics and personal care products because it absorbs moisture. Where talc deposits lie near asbestos, the talc can be contaminated during mining. Asbestos-contaminated talc has been linked to mesothelioma, and talc-related lawsuits also involve ovarian cancer. Whether talc without asbestos causes cancer is less settled: in 2024 the World Health Organization's cancer agency (IARC) classified talc as "probably carcinogenic to humans."
The Issue of Asbestos-Contaminated Talc
Contaminated talc products are a health risk mainly because their dust can be breathed in. In December 2024, FDA proposed a rule that would require standardized testing of talc-containing cosmetics for asbestos. The proposal would require two microscope methods: polarized light microscopy (PLM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM).
FDA proposed the rule because the Modernization of Cosmetics Regulation Act of 2022 (MoCRA) requires it to. The proposal was still open for public comment when the new administration took office, and it is too early to say what will happen to it.
The FDA’s Efforts to Improve Consumer Safety
In recent years, FDA has paid more attention to asbestos in talc. A standardized testing method would be a significant step, because inconsistent testing has long made it hard to keep contaminated products off the market.
What is the FDA proposing on the issue of asbestos-contaminated talc-based products?
The proposed rule would set one testing standard that cosmetics makers must meet, which should reduce the chance of asbestos exposure and improve consumer confidence. But a rule only works if it is enforced, which takes funding and agency leaders who put public health first. Without those, the rule could be more symbolic than real.
If the new administration cuts agency budgets or puts industry interests first, progress on standard testing could stall.
EPA’s Role in Asbestos Regulation Over the Years
EPA began regulating asbestos in the 1970s, driven by growing evidence of its health risks. One of its first actions came in 1973, when it banned spray-applied asbestos materials for fireproofing and insulation in buildings. Asbestos had been sprayed onto steel beams and ceilings in many buildings, including schools.
Congress passed the Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act (AHERA) in 1986. AHERA requires public and private schools to inspect for asbestos-containing materials and to keep management plans to prevent harmful exposure. Those plans include keeping asbestos safely in place when removal isn't needed and following safe procedures during renovation and demolition.
TSCA gave EPA power to restrict or ban asbestos products. The 2016 amendments strengthened that power. Asbestos was among the first ten chemicals EPA evaluated under the amended law, which led to the March 2024 ban on the remaining uses of chrysotile asbestos.
Setbacks Under the Returning Administration
Despite this progress, asbestos remains a hard problem. Some uses were still allowed until the 2024 rule, and that rule phases some of them out over several years. Asbestos also remains in many older buildings, where it can be released as buildings age or are repaired.
During the 2017 to 2021 administration, EPA's work on asbestos faced challenges, including:
- Proposed budget cuts: The administration proposed deep cuts to EPA's budget, which would have reduced its capacity to enforce existing rules.
- The 2019 asbestos rule: In April 2019, EPA issued a rule requiring companies to notify EPA at least 90 days before restarting discontinued uses of asbestos, and barring those uses until EPA reviewed them. EPA said it closed a loophole. Critics said it fell far short of a ban and did nothing about uses still ongoing.
- Industry influence: Critics said pro-business policies put economic goals ahead of public health and delayed stricter rules.
Many advocates fear the next four years could bring similar setbacks.
Current Concerns: The Return of Deregulatory Policies
President Trump's return signals a likely return to pro-industry policies. Key concerns include:
Reduced Agency Capacity
Budget and staff cuts would reduce EPA's and FDA's ability to enforce asbestos rules. Limited resources make it harder to:
- Enforce existing regulations.
- Conduct the inspections needed to make sure rules are followed.
- Develop and put in place new safety standards.
Without these checks, contaminated products can reach the market.
Delayed Reforms
Industry pushback and legal challenges often slow stricter testing standards for substances like talc. The asbestos industry has fought restrictions for decades. Weaker oversight could make it easier for contaminated talc products to reach consumers.
Erosion of Public Trust
When regulators are seen as aligned with industry, public trust suffers. Rebuilding it takes transparency, consistent enforcement and decisions based on evidence.
Some recent developments may shape the administration's choices. In December 2024, EPA issued final rules banning most uses of TCE and perchloroethylene (PERC), citing their links to cancer. Final rules like these are harder to undo than proposals. President Trump's choice to lead the Department of Health and Human Services, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., is known for his environmental advocacy. He may push for stricter controls on some toxic substances, which could lead to debates inside the administration.
Addressing Asbestos in Talc: A Path Forward
Public awareness and ongoing monitoring are vital to addressing asbestos contamination and exposure.
Keeping products free of asbestos takes real enforcement: regular inspections, regular testing of products, and meaningful penalties for companies that don't comply. Consistent oversight is what deters negligence.
Transparency matters too. Publishing test results and clearly labeling products that may contain hazardous materials help consumers make informed choices, and informed consumers push manufacturers to do better.
Newer testing methods can help detect asbestos and lower the risks.
Better science also matters. More sensitive testing methods can find small amounts of asbestos that older methods miss, and independent studies can guide policy.
International cooperation helps as well. Aligning U.S. standards with those of countries that have stronger rules, and sharing data across borders, can improve detection and prevention. Independent nonprofit groups have also played a role by testing products, raising public awareness and pushing for stronger rules.
Significant challenges remain under the new administration. Industry lobbying and resistance to stricter rules continue, and an administration that puts economic growth first may make progress harder.
Decades of weak regulation have left a legacy of asbestos exposure, delayed justice for people who became sick, and eroded trust in regulators. Overcoming that will take public awareness, strong leadership and a steady commitment to public health.
Our take
What this means if you have, or may have, an asbestos claim
Changes in Washington don't change the rights of people who are already sick. Asbestos claims are based on past exposure, often decades ago, and on what manufacturers knew at the time, not on today's regulations. What matters for a claim is your work and product history. If you worked with asbestos or lived with someone who did, write down where and when, and tell your doctor. If you used talc powder and developed mesothelioma, that history matters too. Our page on asbestos-contaminated products explains how talc cases work.
Following this story
The EPA asbestos ban · every post, in order · All posts on this story
- June 7, 2022Environmental Protection Agency Proposes New Asbestos Regulations
- March 22, 2024EPA Unveils Long-Awaited Chrysotile Asbestos Ban
- May 3, 2024Why Did It Take So Long to Ban Asbestos?
- May 21, 2024How the EPA’s Recent Asbestos Ban Affects the Risk
- July 4, 2024Will the SCOTUS Chevron Decision Affect the EPA’s Recent Asbestos Ban?
- August 19, 2024Lawsuits Over EPA Asbestos Ban
- September 2, 2024LABOR DAY: How Does the Latest Asbestos Ban Affect the Industry?
- December 12, 2024Legal Implications of the EPA’s 2024 Asbestos Evaluation
- December 26, 2024Part 2 of EPA’s 2024 Asbestos Evaluation (And Why It Matters)
- February 6, 2025EPA’s Asbestos Ban Under The Trump Administration
- February 17, 2025 · you are hereToxic Substances Control Act Under the New Presidential Administration
- June 16, 2025What’s Next for Asbestos Legislation
- July 7, 2025Trump Administration Reconsiders Biden-era Asbestos Ban
- July 15, 2025Why Weakening the Asbestos Ban Would Be a Bad Idea
- August 5, 2025Asbestos Regulations – What Has Worked?
Read something that sounds familiar? Free case review. No records or product names needed, and no fee unless we recover compensation for your family.
Sources
- Yale Environment 360: How the Trump administration has pulled back on regulating toxic chemicals (2019)
- E&E News: Trump plan takes ax to EPA, environmental spending (2017)
- Covington: FDA issues proposed rule requiring testing of talc-containing cosmetic products for asbestos (December 2024)
- Arnold & Porter: FDA withdraws cosmetics proposed rule on talc (2025)
- EPA: Actions to protect the public from exposure to asbestos
- EPA: 2019 asbestos significant new use rule (Federal Register, April 25, 2019)
- National Law Review: EPA withdraws motion to hold asbestos case in abeyance (July 2025)
- Asbestos, talc and ovarian cancer (IARC talc classification, 2024)
- EPA: Risk management for trichloroethylene (TCE)
- Federal Register, Testing Methods for Detecting and Identifying Asbestos in Talc-Containing Cosmetic Products, withdrawal of proposed rule (November 28, 2025)
This post is news and commentary, provided for general information. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.