No fee unless we recover compensation for your family Text size 833-4-ASBESTOS (833-427-2378) Free Case Review

From the firm

Forever Chemicals and the Next Wave of Environmental Cancer

Are We Replaying the Asbestos Story with Forever Chemicals?

At a meeting in February 2024, a corporate defense lawyer warned a room of plastics industry executives that lawsuits over "forever chemicals" could "dwarf anything related to asbestos," The New York Times reported in May 2024, based on a recording made by someone at the meeting.

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) have become one of the major pollution issues of our time. Used for decades in everyday products, including cosmetics, takeout containers and frying pans, PFAS have been linked to serious health risks, including some cancers. In April 2024 the federal government set drinking water limits for several types of PFAS.

"Do what you can, while you can, before you get sued," attorney Brian Gross of the defense firm MG+M told the executives. He advised them to review their marketing materials and their communications with customers and suppliers for anything that could hurt their defense, and to "weed out people and find the right witness to represent your company."

PFAS are a large family of thousands of man-made chemicals. Many break down very slowly and can build up in people, animals and the environment. According to the EPA, studies have linked PFAS exposure to reproductive effects such as lower fertility and high blood pressure in pregnancy, developmental effects in children, higher risk of prostate, kidney and testicular cancers, weaker immune response, hormone disruption, and higher cholesterol. In 2023 the World Health Organization's cancer agency (IARC) classified one PFAS, PFOA, as carcinogenic to humans, with limited evidence in people for kidney and testicular cancer.

Lawsuits have already been filed against PFAS makers, including 3M, DuPont and DuPont's spinoff Chemours. In 2023, 3M agreed to pay at least $10 billion to public water systems across the United States for PFAS cleanup costs, and a federal court approved the settlement in 2024. Many states have also sued PFAS makers over contamination.

Asbestos and PFAS

Defense lawyers and plaintiffs' lawyers are both preparing for PFAS litigation. As outlined below, the two kinds of cases differ in important ways, but there are some similarities.

Both substances last a long time in the body. PFAS chemicals can build up in the blood and organs over years. Asbestos fibers that are breathed in can stay in the lungs and the lining around them for decades.

Asbestos exposure is the main known cause of mesothelioma, a rare and aggressive cancer of the lining around the lungs or abdomen. Asbestos also causes asbestosis, a scarring of the lungs, and cancers of the lung, larynx and ovary. There is more limited evidence linking it to cancers of the throat (pharynx), stomach and colon.

Cancers Linked to Forever Chemicals

The strongest human evidence for PFAS and cancer concerns kidney and testicular cancer. Other PFAS health effects include reproductive problems, such as high blood pressure in pregnancy, higher cholesterol and a weaker ability to fight infections.

Both PFAS and asbestos have harmed people who worked with them directly and people exposed in other ways. PFAS has been used in grease-resistant food wrappers, firefighting foam, stain-resistant carpet and nonstick cookware, and it is also released as a manufacturing byproduct. Likewise, asbestos victims include people who worked with it (occupational exposure) and people exposed in other ways, such as family members exposed to dust brought home on work clothes, or people in Lower Manhattan after 9/11, when the collapse of the World Trade Center spread dust containing asbestos.

The differences between the two substances, which partly explain the differences in litigation, include what the substance is, where it is found and how it has been regulated.

Distinctions Between Asbestos and PFAS

PFAS are man-made chemicals; asbestos is a natural mineral. PFAS is common in many consumer products. Asbestos was mostly used in industrial and building products, though it also turned up in some consumer products.

As for regulation, the EPA acted on PFAS for years before 2024, including a 2019 PFAS Action Plan, but its first enforceable national drinking water limits for PFAS came in April 2024. Federal limits on asbestos go back to the early 1970s: OSHA's first workplace standard in 1971 to 1972 and EPA's first asbestos air-pollution rule (NESHAP) in 1973.

Litigation Options

Asbestos litigation is well developed and gives people with asbestos diseases several options. People harmed by PFAS have fewer options, at least for now.

Asbestos lawsuits began in earnest in the 1960s and 1970s, as evidence of what manufacturers knew came out. Over the years, several paths have developed (which vary from state to state):

  • Asbestos trusts: Starting in the early 1980s, many asbestos companies filed for bankruptcy. Their reorganization plans set up trusts to pay current and future claims. These trusts hold billions of dollars set aside for people harmed by asbestos.
  • Social Security Disability: SSDI pays people who can no longer work because of a disabling illness, whatever caused it; applicants do not have to prove asbestos caused the illness. Mesothelioma is on Social Security's fast-track Compassionate Allowances list. SSDI recipients become eligible for Medicare after 24 months of benefits.
  • VA Disability and Workers' Compensation: These two are similar in some ways. VA disability applicants must show their illness is connected to military service; workers' compensation applicants must show it is connected to their work. Both can pay medical bills and replace part of lost wages.
  • Civil Claim: An asbestos lawyer usually files a civil lawsuit when possible. Most claim that the defendant failed to warn people about the hazards of its asbestos products; some claim the product was defective. Damages can include medical costs, lost income and pain and suffering, and in some states punitive damages may also be available.

Most of these lawsuits settle out of court. A defendant can tie up a verdict in appeals for years, while a settlement ends the case.

Some of these options, such as disability benefits and workers' compensation, may already be available to people harmed by PFAS in some situations, but most will have to rely on civil claims.

Negligence and defective product claims are usually available. In cases affecting many people, lawyers also often bring public nuisance claims, which argue that the defendant created a hazard affecting the public and failed to address it.

Our take

What this means if you have, or may have, an asbestos claim

PFAS lawsuits don't change anything for asbestos claims, which follow their own well-established paths. If you or a family member has mesothelioma, asbestos lung cancer or asbestosis, you may be able to bring a lawsuit, file with asbestos trusts, and apply for disability benefits, all at once. Start by writing down every job and work site you can remember and the products used there. Our page on asbestos trust claims explains how the trusts work.

Read something that sounds familiar? Free case review. No records or product names needed, and no fee unless we recover compensation for your family.

Call 833-4-ASBESTOS Request a review
Sources

This post is news and commentary, provided for general information. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.