A cautionary tale for anyone in construction: workers say asbestos was swept up and dumped during a shelter renovation.
The December 2024 filing is the latest chapter of a legal fight that began when asbestos was disturbed during renovation of the city's Gateway Center homeless shelter.
The city bought the former Lovelace hospital at 5400 Gibson SE in 2021 to turn it into a shelter and services center, now called the Gibson Health Hub, and hired Consolidated Builders of New Mexico, LLC as the contractor. In February 2024, three lawsuits were filed by a total of 25 former employees who say they were exposed to asbestos between April 2022 and March 2023. They allege that asbestos fireproofing was knocked down from the ceilings during work on the second-floor women's shelter, then swept or shoveled into wheelbarrows and dumped into open bins, and that both the city and Consolidated Builders failed to detect or respond to the asbestos. Those suits seek unspecified damages and were still pending at the end of 2024.
On December 12, 2024, the city filed its own lawsuit against Consolidated Builders, asking a judge to rule that the contractor is bound by its contract to "hold harmless" the city against injury claims by the company's employees, and so must cover the city's costs from the three earlier suits.
State regulators had already found fault on both sides. In September 2023, the New Mexico Environment Department's Occupational Health and Safety Bureau fined the city $761,112 and Consolidated Builders $331,475 for willful and serious violations. Among them: failing to find out where the asbestos was before work began, failing to set up regulated work areas, failing to use wet methods for cleanup, and failing to warn and train workers. The city has offered medical monitoring to people who spent five or more days in the construction area.
Asbestos Legal Actions and Procedural Issues
Asbestos cases are complex, and some of that complexity has nothing to do with the asbestos itself.
The city's suit is an example. It is about who pays among the defendants, under the contract between the city and its contractor. Disputes like this, over indemnity and insurance, happen often in asbestos cases, because a product could pass from a mine to a manufacturer, a distributor and an installer, and each one may share responsibility.
Usually these fights don't change much for the injured person, who may recover from several defendants and trusts. But they can slow a case down.
States also divide responsibility among defendants differently. Under joint and several liability, each responsible defendant can be made to pay the whole judgment and then seek contribution from the others. Many states, including New Mexico, have largely replaced that rule with several liability, where each defendant pays only its own share of the fault, with exceptions. New Mexico, for example, keeps joint liability for makers and sellers of defective products for the share of fault attributed to them. These rules affect how cases are built, which is one reason it matters to identify every company responsible for a person's exposure.
Deadlines
The statute of limitations sets the deadline to file a lawsuit, and it varies by state. In New Mexico, a personal injury case generally must be filed within three years, and courts usually start the clock when the person knew or should have known of the injury and its cause. Some states also have statutes of repose for claims against builders and designers of buildings, which run from the end of construction. Because the rules differ from state to state, check them early. Our page on state asbestos laws explains the deadlines where you live.
Substantive Legal Issues in Asbestos Exposure Cases
A case then turns on three main questions: what disease the person has, what caused it, and whether the defendant was at fault.
Getting the diagnosis right matters. Mesothelioma is rare, and pathologists use special stains and tests to tell it apart from other cancers, such as lung cancer that has spread to the pleura. A diagnosis confirmed by an experienced pathologist is important both for treatment and for a legal claim.
Proving the source of exposure is often the hardest part, because fibers in the lungs can't be traced to a single product. Lawyers build that proof from work histories, coworker testimony, product records, invoices and company documents. Our Library holds many of those historical records.
To prove fault, lawyers often work with experts such as industrial hygienists, who can explain what protections were known and required at the time, and what companies knew about asbestos and failed to tell workers. In some cases, when a company knowingly disregarded the risk, punitive damages may be available, under standards that vary by state.
Resolving the Case
Most asbestos cases settle out of court. A settlement gives certainty and usually pays sooner. A trial can lead to a larger verdict, a smaller one, or none, and a verdict can be appealed, which can delay payment for a long time. Whether to settle is the client's decision, made with the lawyer's advice.
Our take
What this means if you have, or may have, an asbestos claim
If you worked at the Gateway Center site between April 2022 and March 2023, ask your doctor about the exposure and look into the city's medical monitoring. Most asbestos diseases take decades to appear, so a recent exposure is not a diagnosis, and the people we usually help were exposed years ago, in construction, renovation and building maintenance. If that is your history, keep records of where you worked. Our pages on New Mexico exposure sites and exposure and the free health test explain what to do next.
Read something that sounds familiar? Free case review. No records or product names needed, and no fee unless we recover compensation for your family.
Sources
- Albuquerque Journal, Fourth lawsuit filed in asbestos exposure at Gateway Center (December 27, 2024)
- New Mexico Environment Department news release, City of Albuquerque and Consolidated Builders of NM, LLC issued citations for exposing workers to asbestos at Gateway Center (September 1, 2023)
- City of Albuquerque, Risk Management: Medical Monitoring
- N.M. Stat. Ann. § 37-1-8 and § 41-3A-1, as summarized on our New Mexico laws page
This post is news and commentary, provided for general information. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.