No fee unless we recover compensation for your family Text size 833-4-ASBESTOS (833-427-2378) Free Case Review

From the archives

Asbestos Exposed: The Shocking Revelations from Saranac Labs, Part 2

Welcome to part two of "Asbestos Exposed," where we look at how the asbestos industry controlled research it paid for. This part follows the Saranac Laboratory's asbestos experiments, from the 1936 agreement to the report published in 1951.

Backdrop of the Crisis

A quick recap. In the 1930s, the American asbestos industry was large, profitable and barely regulated. Doctors had described asbestosis, a scarring of the lungs, and asbestos workers were filing claims and lawsuits. Most workers had little idea of the danger.

Initial Revelations and the Industry's Reaction

The industry already had evidence of harm. In 1929 it asked the Metropolitan Life Insurance Company to study whether asbestos dust was a hazard, and Metropolitan Life's 1935 report found asbestosis in 67 of 126 workers X-rayed. Before that report was published, Johns-Manville's attorney, Vandiver Brown, reviewed the galley proof and asked that findings "favorable to the industry" be kept in.

The Grand Deception Unfolds

Dr. Anthony Lanza, the Metropolitan Life doctor who led that survey, worked closely with Johns-Manville for many years. The Saranac study, though, was set up directly between Brown and the laboratory's director, Dr. Leroy U. Gardner.

Saranac Laboratories: The Participant

The Saranac Laboratory, a respected tuberculosis research center in Saranac Lake, New York, agreed in November 1936 to study the effects of asbestos dust. A group of asbestos companies paid $5,000 a year for three years. Brown's terms, which Gardner accepted in writing, were that the results belonged to the companies paying for the work, which would decide "whether, to what extent and in what manner they shall be made public," and that any manuscript would be submitted to them for approval before publication (the 1936 agreement and letters).

Dr. Leroy Gardner and the Mice

Gardner's team exposed animals to asbestos dust for long periods, then examined their lungs. The work was mainly about asbestosis, and it ran on long after the first three years.

In March 1943, Gardner told the National Cancer Institute he was "startled" to find lung cancer in 9 of the 11 white mice (81.8 percent) that had breathed asbestos dust for 15 to 24 months, far more than in mice exposed to quartz. He called it an accidental discovery in a small group, and he asked for a grant to repeat the experiment under proper controls (Gardner to Hektoen, 1943). He noted that English doctors already believed asbestos could cause lung cancer.

Asbestos and Cancer: The Question Left Open

Gardner did not publish the cancer finding. He was a cautious scientist: in 1946 he wrote that the link between asbestosis and lung cancer in people had not been proven and that a large study of asbestos workers was needed (Gardner to Woodard, 1946). Meanwhile the companies pressed him for his final report. Brown himself wrote that "when Dr. Gardner states a finding it is quite likely to be correct" (Brown's letters, May 1946).

The Unforeseen Tragedy

Gardner died at home on October 24, 1946, of a coronary embolism, before writing his final report (Bowditch to Brown, 1946). Others at Saranac, with Dr. Lanza, took up the task of finishing it.

Dr. Vorwald: The Successor

Manfred Bowditch served as acting director until Dr. Arthur J. Vorwald took charge of the laboratory. Vorwald and his colleagues finished the report.

The Sanitized Report

In October 1948, Saranac sent the sponsors a draft report that still described tumors in mice exposed to long-fiber asbestos. At a meeting on November 11, the companies agreed that "the references to cancer and tumors should be deleted and this is a point we will insist upon," Brown wrote. They also recalled the copies of the draft, because "it would be most unwise to have any copies of the draft report outstanding" (Brown to Kelly, November 12, 1948). Brown gave reasons, among them that the study had not been designed to look at cancer and that Gardner himself had suggested leaving cancer out.

The report was published in January 1951 in the American Medical Association's industrial hygiene journal. It described asbestosis in the animals in detail, but it does not discuss cancer.

The Continuation

For decades, the public record held a report on asbestos and the lungs with no mention of the tumors Saranac had seen. The letters showing how that happened came out later, through lawsuits.

Stay tuned for the next installment, which looks more closely at Dr. Lanza.

Our take

What this means if you have, or may have, an asbestos claim

The Saranac papers still come up in asbestos cases because they show that the largest manufacturers were told about a possible cancer link in the 1940s and chose to keep it out of print. Evidence like this can matter when a court or jury looks at what a company knew. It doesn't replace the basics of a claim: a diagnosis and proof that you were exposed to a company's products. If you worked with asbestos insulation, textiles, brakes or building products, write down your jobs and products now, and read how asbestos claims work.

Following this story

Saranac lake · every post, in order · All posts on this story

  1. August 14, 2024Asbestos Exposed: The Shocking Revelations from Saranac Labs, Part 1
  2. April 29, 2025 · you are hereAsbestos Exposed: The Shocking Revelations from Saranac Labs, Part 2
  3. April 30, 2025Asbestos Exposed: The Shocking Revelations from Saranac Labs, Part 3

Read something that sounds familiar? Free case review. No records or product names needed, and no fee unless we recover compensation for your family.

Call 833-4-ASBESTOS Request a review
Sources

This post is news and commentary, provided for general information. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.