A hidden hazard in plain sight: what a city audit found about asbestos inspections in New York City schools.
New York City runs the nation's largest school system, and many of its buildings contain asbestos. On April 9, 2025, the New York City Comptroller's Office released an audit finding that the Department of Education (DOE) failed to give 82% of school buildings known to contain asbestos the inspection that federal law requires every three years. Parents, teachers and advocates worry that damaged asbestos could go unnoticed.
The DOE says custodians are trained every year in asbestos awareness and that the city requires testing before any work that drills into or changes a building. But the audit raises a broader question about how old hazardous materials are managed in aging public buildings.
The Audit Findings
The federal Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act (AHERA) requires schools to manage asbestos-containing materials (ACMs) in place. Two kinds of checks matter here: a quick "periodic surveillance" look at known asbestos every six months, and a full reinspection by an accredited inspector every three years. Both are required whether or not any work is planned.
Comptroller Brad Lander's office found that from March 2021 to March 2024, only 257 of 1,431 school buildings with asbestos (18%) got the required three-year reinspection. From May 2023 to April 2024, only 22% of buildings got the required six-month checks. The audit found that since 1997 the DOE had completed an average of 11% of required three-year inspections, and that it would need about 480 inspections a year to keep up. The DOE blamed "insufficient consultant contracts" and agreed with all of the audit's recommendations. According to the audit, P.S. 107 in Brooklyn had not had its required inspection since 2008.
Unequal Protection Across Boroughs
Compliance with the three-year inspections was low everywhere. Brooklyn, with the most school buildings containing asbestos, had the lowest rate at 13%. Queens was at 16%, Manhattan 20%, Staten Island 21%, and the Bronx 25%.
The Invisible Danger of Asbestos
For decades, asbestos was used in building materials for its resistance to fire, heat and chemicals, and because it was cheap. It went into insulation, ceiling tiles, floor tiles and their adhesives, pipe wrap, cement and many other materials inside and outside public buildings. In 1989, EPA issued a rule to ban most asbestos products, but a federal appeals court overturned most of it in 1991. A 2024 EPA rule bans the remaining uses of chrysotile asbestos and is being challenged in federal court. Many older buildings still contain asbestos.
Asbestos-related diseases can take decades to appear.
Asbestos causes mesothelioma, cancers of the lung, larynx and ovary, and asbestosis, a scarring of the lungs. Asbestos fibers are too small to see and have no smell or taste. When asbestos material is damaged or disturbed, fibers can be released into the air, and they can be stirred up again after they settle.
Once released, asbestos fibers can be inhaled.
Inhaled fibers can lodge in the lungs and their lining, causing inflammation and scarring over many years. According to the National Cancer Institute, it can take 10 to 40 years or more for symptoms of an asbestos-related condition to appear.
That long delay is one reason exposure in schools is a particular concern: children who are exposed have many years ahead of them for disease to develop. Asbestos that is intact and undisturbed is a low risk. The danger comes when aging material is damaged, crumbles, or is disturbed by repairs.
The Legal Framework and a Failure to Comply
AHERA was enacted in 1986. It requires public school districts and nonprofit private schools, including charter and religious schools, to inspect for asbestos, keep an asbestos management plan at each school, carry out the periodic checks and reinspections, and notify parent, teacher and employee groups each year. Parents and staff have the right to see a school's management plan, which must be made available within five working days of a request.
Asbestos risks are ongoing in many old buildings like NYC schools.
That is why the audit's findings matter. The DOE says custodians are trained and that testing comes before construction, but those steps do not replace the inspections the law requires when no work is planned. Routine checks are how damage gets caught early.
Community Reactions
Parents interviewed by local news had mixed reactions, from calling asbestos "very concerning" to saying it is "not really an issue" as long as it is sealed. Michael Mulgrew, president of the United Federation of Teachers, said the union sends people to a school the same day it gets a complaint about a damaged ceiling or cracks. Complaint-driven fixes, though, are not a substitute for the inspections the law requires.
The Comptroller himself said the presence of asbestos-containing materials alone does not automatically pose a health risk. But he warned that it only takes one place where fibers are leaking out to harm many students, teachers and parents.
The Widespread Problem of Legacy Asbestos
What is happening in New York City is part of a larger story about aging buildings across the country. Many buildings put up before the 1980s still contain asbestos, including schools, libraries, courthouses, hospitals, transit facilities and workplaces.
The risk goes up during renovation, demolition, disasters and some maintenance work, or when materials are badly damaged. Managing it takes planning, money and trained professionals.
The Importance of Professional Abatement
When asbestos has to be removed, it should be done by licensed professionals. They seal off the work area, wear protective gear, keep fibers from escaping, and dispose of the waste under federal and state rules. Cutting corners can spread contamination.
A cautionary tale comes from Albuquerque, New Mexico. In December 2024, the city sued the contractor it had hired for demolition work at the Gibson Health Hub, a city homeless shelter and health center, after people who worked on the project sued the city, saying they were exposed to asbestos. The case shows how careless work can put workers at risk and lead to years of legal fallout.
A Call to Action
The audit should be a wake-up call. The audit's recommendations include a plan with milestones to bring every school's inspections up to date, better record keeping, and training for custodians and asbestos handlers. Parents and staff can also act: ask your school for its asbestos management plan, read the annual notice, and report damaged ceilings, pipe wrap or floor tiles.
Other places are putting money into the problem. In Allentown, Pennsylvania, the city accepted a federal grant that helps lower-income residents fix health hazards, including asbestos, in their homes.
Our take
What this means if you have, or may have, an asbestos claim
An audit about missed inspections doesn't mean students or staff were exposed, and it doesn't create a legal claim by itself. The people with the most at stake are those who worked in older schools for years, such as custodians, maintenance workers, and the tradespeople who repaired or renovated them, and their families. If that describes you and you have breathing problems or an asbestos-related diagnosis, tell your doctor about the work. Our page on asbestos in schools explains who has been exposed and how those cases work.
Following this story
Asbestos in schools · every post, in order · All posts on this story
- February 4, 2025New Jersey Library Shuts Down for Asbestos Removal: A Vital Safety Measure
- April 24, 2025 · you are here80% of NYC Schools Built with Asbestos Were Not Inspected: What Parents (and Students) Need to Know
- April 28, 2025Spring Break is a Time For… Asbestos?
Read something that sounds familiar? Free case review. No records or product names needed, and no fee unless we recover compensation for your family.
Sources
- NYC Comptroller, Audit finds Education Dept failed to inspect 82% of schools containing asbestos (April 9, 2025)
- NYC Comptroller, Audit report on the DOE/SCA asbestos management program
- CBS New York, NYC public schools asbestos inspection audit (April 2025)
- NBC New York, NYC school asbestos inspections badly lacking (April 2025)
- Chalkbeat New York, Asbestos inspections lacking at NYC schools, audit finds (April 9, 2025)
- EPA, Asbestos and School Buildings
- EPA, Actions to Protect the Public from Exposure to Asbestos
- National Cancer Institute, Asbestos Exposure and Cancer Risk
This post is news and commentary, provided for general information. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.